The Best Collaborative Decision-Making Tools

The most effective decisions—the kind of decisions that take your company to the next level—are rarely solo endeavors. They come from bringing together team members with different strengths, perspectives, and ideas—and then tapping into that collective intelligence to determine the right path forward.

But collaborative decision-making doesn’t just happen—especially if you have a remote or hybrid team. To foster effective collaboration in decision-making, your team needs more than good intentions — they need the right access. That means being able to connect easily with each other and access the right information at the right time.

The best way to enable that? A collaborative decision-making tool that centralizes communication and makes participation easy for everyone. Let’s take a look at some of the top collaborative decision-making tools, including what they offer, the pros and cons of each, and how to choose the right tool for your business.

1. Talkspirit

If you’re looking for an all-in-one collaborative decision-making platform that helps you move from purpose to impact, look no further than Talkspirit. Unlike other collaborative decision-making tools, which only address parts of the decision-making process, Talkspirit offers solutions that support every step of decision-making. From information sharing to collaboration, communication to project management, and just about everything in between—Talkspirit has what you need, all in one streamlined, easy-to-use platform. 

Key features:

• Meetings. Customizable templates, shared agendas, videoconferencing and action tracking to enhance collaborative decision-making—all of which lead to more structured and effective meetings
• Proposals. Collaborative development and asynchronous validation of ideas with status tracking for team visibility—ensuring each team member is in the loop on the proposal’s current status
• Goal setting and project management. Set organizational and team goals using the OKR method, build projects around those goals, and manage the project all within the Talkspirit platform
• Org chart. AI-powered visualization of organizational structure that enables clear understanding of roles and responsibilities
• Library. Centralized, searchable knowledge base for accessing decision-making processes, policies, and past decisions
• Integrated communication. Streamline discussions using chat rooms and poll your team in organized, searchable groups to keep decisions accessible. Use the newsfeed to share information with your teams asynchronously.

Strengths:

• Offers collaborative features that creates transparency and make it easy for teams to work together at every stage of the process. The platform also supports consent-based decision-making, which can be useful for organizations looking to implement frameworks like Holacracy or sociocracy
• Unifies often disconnected communication, collaboration, and decision functions into one platform. This eliminates the need to switch tools (which can lead to miscommunications, oversights, and other decision-related issues)
• Intuitive, easy-to-use interface allows teams to easily and quickly integrate the platform into their workflows
• Creates a comprehensive, searchable database of decisions—including who made them, why they were made, and what the desired outcome is—which can help support future decision-making efforts
• Has a network of 160+ agile coaches who support you not only in implementing the tool, but also in driving organizational change 

Weaknesses:

• Like any platform, you’ll need to train your team on how to use Talkspirit and integrate it into their decision-making
• Mobile app doesn’t have all the features available on desktop

Pricing:

Pricing quotes available; reach out to us for more information

Ready to experience how Talkspirit can help transform the way your organization makes decisions? Schedule a demo today!

2. Notion

Notion offers an all-in-one collaborative workspace for tasks, databases, and notes, allowing users to effectively organize, plan, and share information and partner on tasks and projects from one interface—which, in turn, can support collaborative decision-making.

Key features:

• Fully customizable, allowing users to organize, design, and share key information in a variety of ways
• Templates for decision documentation, including decision-making matrices
• Database functionality for organizing decision-related data
• Project management features for tracking the decision-making process
• Team wikis make it easy to organize decision-related information—and ensure key stakeholders have access
• Permission controls ensure only authorized users are looped into sensitive decisions

Strengths:

• Highly customizable, which enables teams to design an effective, personalized decision-making workflow
• Strong knowledge management capabilities make for easy information sharing
• Simple, intuitive interface 

Weaknesses:

• The platform lacks functionality for more formal or intricate decision-making processes
• No integrated meeting or chat features
• Can take time to set up optimized workspaces

Pricing:

Starting at $10/user/month. Free plan also available (although features are limited)

3. Loomio

Loomio is a collaborative decision-making platform specifically designed to help teams make better decisions through structured discussion and voting processes—no meetings required. 

Key features:

• Create threads to organize decision-related conversations
• Multiple decision tools (for example, proposals and polls)
• Different voting options (for example, thumbs up/thumbs down, multiple choice, etc.)
• Create time-bound decision processes, ensuring decisions are made on deadline
• Asynchronous voting capabilities
• Creates charts/visual representations of team voting
• Creates a record of decision-making processes

Strengths:

• Designed specifically for collaborative decisions
• Threads give users access to key conversations and insights needed to make informed decisions
• Easy-to-use interface
• Easily gather input/insights from team members
• Great for wider-scale decision making
• Ideal for companies that want to minimize meetings

Weaknesses:

• Limited integration with other workplace tools
• Lacks features for certain parts of the decision-making process (for example, project management or meetings)
• Not as customizable when compared to other shared decision-making tools

Pricing:

Plans starting at $39/month. Free 14-day trial available.

4. Miro

Miro is an AI-powered visual collaboration platform that supports decision-making through interactive whiteboards, frameworks, and templates. 

Key features:

• Intelligent Canvas allows for collaborative brainstorming and decision-making—and then turns those sessions into product briefs, summaries, and other documents to help teams move forward
• Customizable templates, including decision matrix templates
• Multiple voting tools (for example, flash polls and dot voting)
• Real-time collaboration 

Strengths:

• Excellent for brainstorming and ideation
• Ideal tool for visual thinkers/learners
• Variety of templates
• Offers integrations with a variety of other productivity and project management tools

Weaknesses:

• Less structured than platforms designed specifically for collaborative decision-making
• Can become disorganized and/or visually overwhelming, making it difficult for users to access the information they need
• Can take significant customization for best results

Pricing:

Plans starting at $8/user/month. Free plan also available (although features are limited)

5. MURAL

MURAL is a visual collaboration platform that allows teams to ideate, align, and execute on company objectives and strategies—including making key decisions.

Key features:

• Visual workspaces make it easy for teams to collaborate in real time
• Pre-built templates to support a variety of decision-making frameworks
• Voting sessions allow users to poll their collaborators
• Private mode allows team members to contemplate decisions without being influenced by others—which can help ensure teams make the right decision and aren’t influenced by group thought

Strengths:

• Great tool for brainstorming and collaboration
• Ideal fit for visual learners
• Supports both synchronous and asynchronous work, allowing teams to collaborate in a variety of ways—and make decisions on their own time
• Integrates with a variety of productivity, project management, and work-related apps
• Strong focus on security and compliance

Weaknesses:

• There can be a learning curve for non-visual thinkers and/or less tech savvy team members
• Can become visually overwhelming
• Can require a high level of customization for best results
• Limited project management capabilities

Pricing:

Starting at $9.99/user/month (free plan available)

6. Smartsheet

For more data-driven decision making, Smartsheet combines the functionality and familiarity of a good old-fashioned spreadsheet with powerful collaboration features, allowing teams to better organize, share, and understand key data—and then leverage that understanding to make better decisions, together.

Key features:

• Easily organize and view data in a variety of formats
• File library allows you to store all decision-related documentation and data in one place
• Centralized discussions and decision-related conversations
• Ability to pull in live data from external sources to aid in decision-making
• Formulas and functions to streamline data analysis and make decisions faster
• Customizable forms for polling team members and collecting data

Strengths:

• Ideal choice for data-heavy and/or process-oriented decisions
• Works for a variety of learning/work styles, as data can be displayed in different ways (Gantt chart, grid, spreadsheet, calendar, etc.)
• Permission controls allow you to control who can access what—and how they can interact with the data/document—at each stage of the decision-making process

Weaknesses:

• More geared towards data-oriented project management—and, as such, sn’t the best fit for all types of decision-making (or documenting the decision-making process)
• More geared towards data-oriented projects
• Less intuitive/higher learning curve than other options
• Can be overwhelming/overly complex for simple decisions

Pricing:

Plans starting at $9/user/month. Free trial available.

Choosing the Right Collaborative Decision-Making Tool

Now that you know some of the top shared decision-making tools on the market, the next question is—how do I determine which one is right for my team and organization?

Some key factors to keep in mind when evaluating collaborative decision-making tools include:

• Decision types. What types of decisions will your team be making—and what kind of features do you need to support them in that decision-making process? For example, are your employees remote—and need the ability to collaborate on documents in real-time? Or do you need features that speak to specific parts of the decision-making process (like brainstorming or documentation)? Understanding how your collaborative decision-making tools are going to be used will help you determine which is ultimately the best fit for your team.
• Team structure. How your team will be collaborating also plays a big role in what kind of tool will be best. For example, if your team is entirely remote, you’re going to want to look for extensive collaborative and asynchronous features—while those things might be less important if you share an office space.
• Current tech stack. If you need your structured decision-making tool to integrate with other applications in your tech stack, it’s important to make sure the tool offers those integrations—or go with a tool that offers a more all-in-one type of experience (like Talkspirit). 
• Scale. Another factor to consider is scale. How many team members are going to be participating in the collaborative decision-making process? The best tool for a team of 5 may not be the best tool for a team of 500. And, if you have plans to scale your organization in the future, make sure to keep that in mind—and choose a tool that will scale with your team.
• Budget. Collaborative decision-making tools come at a variety of price points—so it’s important to choose a tool that works with your budget.

• Governance requirements. Different tools offer different levels of transparency, documentation, and compliance—so make sure to choose a tool that aligns with your corporate governance requirements.
• Security. If your organization manages sensitive data and/or operates in certain sectors (like public administration, healthcare, or finance), it’s also extremely important to consider the security of collaborative decision-making tools. Before choosing a tool, review their security protocols, certifications, and compliance procedures—and make sure that it aligns with your organization’s needs.

Wrapping things up

The right collaborative decision-making tool empowers teams to make better decisions. Not only does it give them access to the right information at the right time, but it also supports them in better understanding that information and working together to make a more informed decision that aligns with your company’s goals. And the best way to foster more collaborative decision-making? Organizational transparency and choosing the right organizational framework for your team.

For more on the different organizational frameworks—and how they impact collaborative decision-making—make sure to download The Ultimate guide to organizational models 👇

Access the White Paper

In our white paper, “The Ultimate Guide to Organizational Models,” you’ll receive:

• a comprehensive overview of innovative organizational models (like Agile, Teal, Holacracy, Constitutional Management, and more)
• testimonials from pioneer organizations that have successfully adopted it
• best practices for choosing, implementing, and measuring the effectiveness of our model
• digital tools to facilitate your transition