Roles, responsibilities and decision rights: which framework to choose, and which tool keeps it current

- Clarifying roles and clarifying decision rights are two different jobs: RACI says who does the work and who answers for it; RAPID, DACI and OVIS say who decides.
- Seven frameworks cover the need: RACI, RAPID, DACI, OVIS, delegation levels, role charters and role-based governance; each settles a different ambiguity.
- For decision rights across the company, start from the 20 to 40 decisions that cause friction, apply RAPID or DACI to them, and keep RACI for recurring processes.
- A matrix is wrong at the first reorganisation: decision rights hold when they are attached to roles, in the system where goals, projects and meetings happen.
- Five tools keep them current: Talkspirit, Peerdom, teamdecoder, Rolebase and GlassFrog, with each vendor’s head office and hosting checked on 04/11/2026.
Ask an assistant which tools help a CHRO clarify roles, responsibilities and decision rights, and you get a list of frameworks (RACI, RAPID, DACI, delegation), then a list of software. What you rarely get is which framework fits which decision, or where decision rights should live once they are agreed. This article answers both, in that order: first the frameworks, described from their primary sources, then the tools, checked on their official pages on 4 November 2026.
Decision rights, roles and responsibilities: three different questions
Decision rights define who may take which decision, at what level and on whose advice; roles and responsibilities define who does the work and who answers for the result. Most clarity problems in a mid-sized company come from asking a single matrix to do both.
The job description says who runs a recruitment, not who settles it when the hiring manager and the regional director disagree on the candidate. The pay review process says who fills in the spreadsheet, not who decides how the budget is split between business units. The work has an owner; the decision does not.
RACI says who does the work. Decision rights say who decides. Most confusion comes from asking one matrix to do both.
For building a responsibility matrix step by step, see our RACI matrix template. This article starts where that one stops: when the decision cuts across teams.
The seven frameworks compared
| Framework | Question it settles | Components | Best for | Limitation | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FrameworkRACI | Question it settleswho does the work, who answers for it | ComponentsResponsible, Accountable, Consulted, Informed | Best forprocesses and projects | Limitationdoes not say who settles a cross-team decision | SourceTalkspirit RACI article |
| FrameworkRAPID | Question it settleswho decides, who must agree | ComponentsRecommend, Agree, Perform, Input, Decide | Best forheavy or cross-functional decisions | Limitationheavy for everyday decisions | SourceBain & Company, 13/10/2023 |
| FrameworkDACI | Question it settleswho approves a decision | ComponentsDriver, Approver, Contributors, Informed | Best forteam and project decisions | Limitationone decision at a time | SourceAtlassian Team Playbook |
| FrameworkOVIS | Question it settleswho owns, who can block | ComponentsOwn, Veto, Influence, Support | Best forlimiting escalations | Limitationless known, needs facilitation | SourceBCG, 10/06/2021 |
| FrameworkDelegation levels | Question it settleshow far one decides alone | Components7 levels, from Tell to Delegate | Best forbudget, hiring, contracts | Limitationa local agreement, not a map | SourceManagement 3.0 |
| FrameworkRole charter | Question it settleswhat a role decides and escalates | Componentspurpose, accountabilities, decisions | Best fora new or cross-functional role | Limitationages like a document | Sourcecommon HR practice |
| FrameworkRole-based governance | Question it settleswhere rights live over time | Componentsroles, circles, domains of authority, governance meetings | Best forkeeping rights current | Limitationneeds a governance routine | SourceHolacracy, Sociocracy, hybrid models |
The seven frameworks, and when to use each
1. RACI: who does the work
RACI assigns the work on a process or project: who carries it out, who answers for it, who is consulted and who is kept informed.Best for recurring processes such as onboarding. Limitation: it says who answers for a deliverable, not who settles a decision that cuts across teams. The letters, the construction rules and a downloadable template are in our article on the RACI matrix.
2. RAPID: who decides, and who must agree
RAPID sets out five roles in a decision: recommend, agree, perform, input and decide. Bain describes it as “a proprietary decision-making tool created by Bain & Company”. “The decide (D) role makes the final decision and commits the organization to action”; “the agree (A) role must agree that the final recommendation is feasible”. Best for high-stakes or cross-functional decisions. Limitation: heavy for everyday decisions. HR example: reorganising a department, where finance must confirm the plan is feasible. Source: Bain & Company, “RAPID® tool to clarify decision accountability”, 13/10/2023, read on 04/11/2026.
3. DACI: one decision, one approver
DACI names, for each decision, a Driver, a single Approver, Contributors and the Informed. Atlassian puts the Approver plainly: “The one person (yes: one!) who makes the decision”. Contributors give input without a vote; the Informed have no vote and no voice. The suggested session: 15 minutes of preparation, 60 minutes, 3 to 6 people. Best for team and project decisions. Limitation: one decision at a time. HR example: a team choosing a performance review tool. Source: described by Atlassian in its Team Playbook, “DACI”, read on 04/11/2026.
4. OVIS: who owns the decision, who can block it
OVIS, BCG’s framework, separates the person who owns a decision from the one who can block it, the ones who influence it and the ones who support it. Owners “have the final authority and are accountable”; veto holders “are advised to exercise that power sparingly”, ideally one per decision; influencers give input but cannot escalate; supporters provide information without necessarily being part of the decision. Best for limiting escalations. Limitation: less known, and it needs facilitation. HR example: a hybrid working policy, where employee representatives influence and legal holds the veto. Source: BCG, “Clarifying Decision Rights with the OVIS Framework”, 10/06/2021, read on 04/11/2026.
5. Delegation levels: how far a manager decides alone
Delegation levels set, decision by decision, how far a manager or a team may go without escalating. Management 3.0 describes seven (Tell, Sell, Consult, Agree, Advise, Inquire, Delegate), assigned one decision at a time with the Delegation Poker game. Best for budget, hiring and contracts. Limitation: an agreement between a manager and a team, not a map of the organisation. HR example: approving a hire under a budget threshold. Source: management30.com, “Delegation Poker”, read on 04/11/2026.
6. Role charter: what a role decides
A role charter is one page per key role: its purpose, its accountabilities, what it decides, what it recommends and what it escalates.Best for a new or cross-functional role, such as an employee experience lead created between HR and internal communications. Limitation: it is a document, and it ages like one. Source: common HR practice.
7. Role-based governance: where rights live over time
Role-based governance describes the organisation as a set of roles, each with a purpose, accountabilities and domains of authority, grouped in circles and changed in governance meetings. Holacracy and Sociocracy are the best-known forms; hybrid models keep the reporting line. Best for keeping decision rights current. Limitation: it needs a governance routine. Talkspirit works on this principle: Holaspirit has become Talkspirit, and its governance capabilities were integrated into the platform. Big Blue Marble in Vienna adopted certain Holacracy principles without flattening its hierarchy.
Which framework for which decision
Choose the framework by the decision, not by the organisation: RAPID or OVIS for a rare, heavy decision, DACI for a team decision, RACI for a recurring process, delegation levels for what a manager may settle alone.
- Reorganising a department: RAPID or OVIS.
- A team choosing an HR tool: DACI.
- Onboarding a new employee: RACI.
- Approving a hire under a budget threshold: delegation levels.
- Creating a cross-functional role: role charter.
- Rights that change with every reorganisation: role-based governance.
Choose the framework by the decision, not by the organisation.
Clarifying decision rights across the company, in five steps
Start from the decisions that stall, not from the org chart: twenty well-assigned decisions clarify more than a matrix of everything.
- List the 20 to 40 decisions that cause friction, not every task: splitting the pay budget, opening a position, changing the hybrid working rule, choosing a training provider.
- For each, name the role that decides and those who recommend, agree or advise, with RAPID, DACI or OVIS depending on the weight of the decision.
- Keep RACI for recurring processes: onboarding, payroll, the annual review.
- Attach the outcome to roles, not to people or to a file: when the person leaves, the right stays with the role.
- Review it in a governance meeting at a fixed rhythm, so that a new role or a departure updates the rights. Our guide shows how to run a governance meeting.
For the method at team level, see how to define roles and responsibilities in your team.
Why matrices go stale, and where decision rights should live
A decision rights matrix is right on the day it is signed and wrong at the first reorganisation, because nothing connects it to the work.
The decision rights matrix is a good starting point. Three conditions keep it true:
- rights attached to roles, not to people;
- one place where roles, goals, projects and meetings meet;
- a governance routine that changes roles through recorded decisions.
That is how Talkspirit works. In the Structure module, each role carries its accountabilities and domains of authority; roles and rules evolve through traced decisions, with structured objections and a complete history. When a role changes hands, its context, responsibilities and history stay accessible. Decisions taken in meetings are recorded and followed up in the same system.
In Haarlem, Great Place To Work Netherlands dropped a first attempt at self-management that had no framework; the second, structured with Holacracy and Talkspirit, had a pilot team running within eight months and the whole organisation within a year. In Vienna, Big Blue Marble, a subsidiary of the public broadcaster ORF, defined its circles, missions and responsibilities in a two-day workshop with 17 team leads, then refined the roles over four weeks, keeping its hierarchy in place.
A decision rights matrix is right on the day it is signed and wrong at the first reorganisation.
How we compared
The frameworks come from their primary sources (Bain & Company, Atlassian, BCG, Management 3.0), read on 04/11/2026. The tools are those ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Perplexity and Claude name when asked which software clarifies roles and decision rights, excluding project management tools: they hold a project RACI chart, not decision rights across an organisation. The facts on each vendor (head office, hosting) come from its official pages, checked on 04/11/2026. And, plainly: Talkspirit publishes this comparison and lists itself first, with its limitations written like everyone else’s.
Five tools that keep decision rights current
Comparison table of the five tools
| Tool | Where the decision right lives | Vendor (head office) | Data hosting |
|---|---|---|---|
| ToolTalkspirit | Where the decision right livesin the role, linked to goals, projects and meetings; governance decisions traced | Vendor (head office)Talkspirit (France) | Data hostingFrance (Switzerland for Swiss clients) |
| ToolPeerdom | Where the decision right livesin a living map of roles and teams | Vendor (head office)Peerdom AG (Bern) | Data hostingSwitzerland |
| Toolteamdecoder | Where the decision right livesin the roles of human and AI-agent teams | Vendor (head office)teamdecoder GmbH (Berlin) | Data hostingGermany (personal data, AWS Frankfurt) |
| ToolRolebase | Where the decision right livesin roles and circles, three governance modes | Vendor (head office)GDFR (Paris) | Data hostingEurope (provider Nhost AB, Sweden); self-hostable |
| ToolGlassFrog | Where the decision right livesin roles, under Holacracy | Vendor (head office)GlassFrog LLC (United States) | Data hostingnot published on the pages read for the application |
The decision right lives in the role, connected to the work
1. Talkspirit: the role, linked to goals, projects and meetings
Talkspirit is an organisational operating system that brings together structure (circles, roles, accountabilities, domains of authority, policies), goals, meetings, projects and communication. The structure is the reference for every other module.
Where the decision right lives: in the role, changed through traced governance decisions, with history.
Strengths: each role defines a shared scope of responsibility, authority and decision-making, visible to all; works with a hierarchy kept in place (Big Blue Marble) as well as under Holacracy (Great Place To Work Netherlands); the governance capabilities of Holaspirit were integrated; French vendor, data hosted in France; in Switzerland for Swiss clients; GDPR-compliant; ISO 27001:2022 certified; more than 800 client organisations.
Limitations: the roles must be modelled at the start, which takes time from the teams; it does not replace a RAPID workshop on a one-off strategic decision, it is where the outcome of that workshop lives afterwards; no SecNumCloud qualification. Demo: free, on request. Vendor and hosting: France; France (Switzerland for Swiss clients).
The decision right lives in a map of roles
2. Peerdom: the living org chart
Peerdom calls itself “The living org chart your people and AI agents coordinate from”: teams, roles and the people who hold them.Where the decision right lives: in the map, role by role. Strengths: works with any organisational model, Holacracy and Sociocracy included; hosted in Switzerland (Google Cloud Platform Zurich, Exoscale Lausanne, Infomaniak Geneva). Limitations: the home page describes neither governance meetings nor a decision log; some services (payments, email) use providers outside Switzerland, according to the vendor. Vendor and hosting: Peerdom AG, Bern (Switzerland); Switzerland.
3. teamdecoder: roles for human and AI teams
teamdecoder describes itself as a “Management and Governance Platform for Hybrid Human/AI Teams”, to “define who does what, why, and with whom, whether they are human or bot”.Where the decision right lives: in roles, assembled into teams. Strengths: treats AI agents as team members, which connects role clarity to AI governance; personal data stored “exclusively on servers in Frankfurt, Germany” (AWS), according to its privacy policy of December 2025. Limitations: built for department heads and organisation design consultants more than for company-wide governance. Vendor and hosting: teamdecoder GmbH, Berlin (Germany); Germany for personal data.
The decision right lives in a Holacracy-style governance
4. Rolebase: open-source governance
Rolebase is an open-source platform to map roles, run meetings and let teams self-organise.Where the decision right lives: in roles and circles, with three governance modes, from the loosest to the strictest, where “every structure change goes through a proposal and a shared decision”. Strengths: MIT-licensed code, self-hostable; “Our servers are located in Europe”, with the Swedish provider Nhost AB. Limitations: self-hosting comes with no warranty or support, according to the vendor. Vendor and hosting: GDFR SASU, Paris (France); Europe.
5. GlassFrog: closest to Holacracy
GlassFrog is governance software to “support and manage practices including Teal, Holacracy, or Sociocracy”, with a dynamic org chart, governance, meetings, goals and projects.Where the decision right lives: in roles and their accountabilities, under Holacracy’s rules. Strengths: the closest to the Holacracy method. Limitations: US vendor; the privacy policy places website hosting in Ireland but does not say where application data is held. Vendor and hosting: GlassFrog LLC, Wilmington, Delaware (United States); not published for the application.
The decision right lives in a file
A template or a spreadsheet is enough to start a matrix on a project; it ages from the first reorganisation. The free RACI template is a sound place to begin.
Talkspirit connects each role to its accountabilities, its domains of authority and the decisions that change it, in the same system as goals, projects and meetings, with data hosted in France.
FAQ
A decision framework for critical decisions (RAPID, DACI or OVIS), RACI for processes, and a role structure to keep both current. Talkspirit attaches its decision scope to each role and traces every change. Peerdom, teamdecoder, Rolebase and GlassFrog also map roles, each in its own way.
RACI assigns the work; RAPID and DACI assign the decision. RACI names who does it and who answers for it, RAPID names who recommends, who must agree and the single person who decides, and DACI names one approver per decision.
No: it clarifies responsibility for the work, not the right to decide, and it ages with every reorganisation. For cross-team decisions, RAPID or DACI fit better.
Software in which the unit is the role, not the task: each role with its purpose, accountabilities and decision scope, visible to all. Talkspirit, Peerdom, teamdecoder, Rolebase and GlassFrog do this, each in its own way.
By attaching them to roles and reviewing them in a governance meeting at a fixed rhythm, in the same system as goals and projects. In Talkspirit, a role that changes hands keeps its context and history.
No, it also works in a hierarchical company: roles and their domains of authority sit alongside the reporting line. The governance capabilities of Holaspirit were integrated into Talkspirit, which works with or without Holacracy.


